Worked example

The AI value framework applied to learning and development

The three paths to value, worked through one function. L&D is a useful example because all three paths are live in it at once, and because the third one changes who does the work rather than how fast it goes.

Why work an example

The three paths are easy to agree with and hard to apply. Teams sort their own candidates onto the wrong path, usually by filing a productivity gain as a disruption because it feels ambitious. Working one function end to end makes the boundaries concrete.

Boost productivity: the same work, faster

This is where most functions start, and it is a real gain. It is also where most stop, which is the failure mode the framework is built to catch: tools rolled out, workflows unchanged.

Create value: something the function could not offer before

These are new offerings rather than faster versions of old ones. The test is whether a learner could have got the same thing before and simply waited longer. If they could, it belongs on the first path.

Disrupt models: who does the work changes

This path is uncomfortable because it puts the function’s own shape in scope, including which parts are bought in. It is also where the durable advantage sits, and it is the reason the three paths are scored separately rather than ranked against each other.

Applying this to your own function

  1. 1
    List the candidates without sorting them

    Collect what people have already tried, asked for, or seen elsewhere. Sorting during collection loses the ones that sound too small.

  2. 2
    Place each one on a path

    Ask what the person on the receiving end could have got before. Same thing faster is the first path, something previously unavailable is the second, a change in who produces it is the third.

  3. 3
    Compare within a path, not across

    A productivity gain and a business model change do not belong on one ranked list, and comparing them is how a portfolio collapses into a pile of quick wins.

  4. 4
    Name an owner per path

    The first path belongs to functional leaders, the second to product and function together, the third to the executive team. A path with no owner at the right level does not move.

How this is delivered

Use-case discovery runs this exercise on the client’s own candidates and leaves a prioritized portfolio with the reasons for what did not make the cut.

Further reading: Amir Elion writes about AI in organizational learning at amirelion.com.

Related: The AI value framework · AI Advisory: Strategy, Enablement and Adoption

Discuss an AI engagement